A Poached Quince Cake
I ate the last of it for breakfast this morning, warmed in the microwave, a few blobs of butter on top. Took half into work last week and my colleagues approved – except for Frank who, with the, um, frankness you would expect, told me it was a bit dry. And, after all, this is a man who makes his own, very fine, quince paste, so I should be honoured, I suppose, that he deigned even to taste my far humbler creation. (The slice of paste that he gave me a month or two back mysteriously disappeared, as did some stinky soft French cheese, before I could reach for my camera.)
It’s a Quince Cake. A Poached Quince Cake. With raisins and toasted walnuts. Based on a recipe for Persimmon Cake I found in Chez Panisse Cooking (by Paul Bertolli with Alice Waters, Random House, 1988).
I was playing with fire I suppose, to fiddle with a recipe like that when I’m not a natural baker: I don’t think I’ve ever had persimmon, so have no idea whether its texture, sugar content, composition etc, is remotely similar to that of a quince. Not surprising really, that my cake with quince was good, but not great.
I work on the principal that I’ll only post recipes here that I’ve tested, which I know are great, and that I’m confident you’ll have success with and enjoy. I’d normally retest the quince cake until I was 100% happy with it. But, I’m going to make an exception with this: quinces are almost out of the markets for the season and, even if I can get hold of some, I may not have the energy to poach another batch – all that tough skin and core to peel and cut away, a sugar syrup to be made … quinces can be too much like hard work.
So I’m going to put this recipe out there, suggest it as an idea — and treat this post as a note to myself for next year, to remind myself of what I’d adjust, change, fiddle with to perfect my quince cake recipe. And please: hit me with your suggestions.
My notes to myself:
- It was a bit dry: I knew that would be the case the moment I opened the oven at the 50-minute mark. Perhaps they didn’t have fan-forced ovens in 1988? With 25 minutes to go according to Messrs Bertolli and Waters, my cake was well and truly ready. Next time, I’ll be checking it at 40 minutes and possibly pulling back on the temperature.
- I only had about 1 ¼ cup poached quinces left, so used a bit of the poaching syrup to get me closer to the 1 ½ cup mark. Next time, I’d consider taking that up to maybe 2 cups of poached quinces.
- Some interesting information I picked up during the week: for the magazine’s September food edition, I was editing a piece about the Royal Melbourne Show’s cooking competitions (an agricultural show). To check some recipe details, I had to call one of the champion bakers (her shortbread is a trophy-winner). At the end of our conversation, I asked her why my quince cake might have been dry (beyond the obvious reasons). She said that, because of Australia’s prolonged drought, she has found flour to be considerably drier and is having to add more liquid, be it eggs, milk or other, when she bakes.
- The Chez Panisse recipe calls for the persimmon to be pureed until there are no lumps of fruit; I had wanted to have some fruit texture in my cake, so left a few chunks, but they really weren’t noticeable. Nor did the cake have much of a quince flavour. Next time, I might try making an old-fashioned apple tea cake like this one – except with the poached quinces.
- The syrup addition below was mine; a desperate, last-minute inspiration drawn from my lemon cake recipe that saved the quince cake from being dreadful.
- I served it with a dollop of yoghurt: both to add moisture and cut the sweetness.
Poached Quince Cake
1 ½ cups poached quince, mashed with a fork*
1 cup coarsely chopped walnuts
2 ¼ cups plain flour
1 ½ tsp ground cinnamon
pinch salt
3 eggs
1 1/8 cups caster sugar
¾ cup pure olive oil
1 ½ tsp baking soda (bi-carb soda)
¾ cup dark raisins
½ cup quince syrup (from poaching the fruit)
Preheat oven to 350ºF (about 180ºC). Lightly toast the walnuts in the oven for 5 minutes, then reduce the oven temperature to 325ºF (160ºC) . Butter and flour a 9-inch (23cm) cake pan (it needs to be fairly deep.)
In bowl 1: sift together the flour, cinnamon and salt.
In bowl 2: mix together the eggs, sugar and olive oil.
In bowl 3: whisk mashed quince with baking soda until well mixed.
Add quince puree to egg mixture and combine well. Fold the dry ingredients into the quince mixture until well combined. Fold in the walnuts and raisins.
Pour the batter into the cake pan and bake for about 50 minutes, or until a skewer comes out clean. Warm the quince syrup and skewer the cake top in a few places. Pour syrup over the cake and allow to cool in the pan.
* I use Stephanie Alexander’s recipe for poached quinces in The Cook's Companion (Viking, 1996): 6 quinces (washed and peeled), 2.25 litres sugar syrup, 1 vanilla bean, juice of 1 lemon. The quince cores are not discarded; rather, Alexander ties them in muslin and they get poached with the fruit and syrup – in a large enamelled, cast-iron lidded casserole at 150ºC for up to 8 hours (I find 3 hours is plenty).






